This date marks a quasi copernican revolution of the entire uk system of company law. The concept of legal personality was discussed in chapter 4. Advantages and disadvantages of incorporation of a company. Pulling back the curtains separate legal personality and. Jan 30, 2015 the paper deals with the concept of the separate legal entity of a corporation. It follows that the companys condition of a separate legal personality entails that when a company has to decide or act for define its legal relationships with the real. Cases on separate legal entity kandoli tea company ltd1886 facts certain persons transferred their properties in the name of company on which tax was payable. Under english company law the company is a separate legal entity.
A registered company is a body corporate companies act 2006 ca 2006, s. The consequences of a corporate personality law company. A different approach here with no need to lift the veil and the possibility of direct legal liability for the holding company as a tortfeasor. The consequences of a corporate personality have significant affects for corporations and its members. Legal personality, being an artificial creation of the law, may be conferred on entities other individual human beings. Dec 17, 2007 the concept of corporate personality has long been a significant issue in the study of corporate law and commercial systems in general, and raises a number of concerns regarding how a company is to be treated in the eyes of the law. First, it may mean that there is a veil or mask or curtain between the members of the company and outsiders which is, in this sense, cc lifted when the law goes behind the corporate personality to the individual members. Nov 06, 2011 a separate legal entity may be set up in the case of a corporation or a limited liability company, to separate the actions of the entity from those of the individual or other company. Equally notably, separate legal personality ensures that a company is independent of the people who form, manage, direct and invest in it, separating the duties and rights of a corporation from the rights and duties of its directors and shareholders.
Separate legal personality of a company lawteacher. Separate legal entity doctrine and its exceptions studentvip. One argument against mr salomon was that he fraudulently incorporated the company contrary to the true and intent meaning of the companies act, hence he should be liable for all its debts. This is confirmed in the house of law in the case of salomon vs. The difficulties experienced by the courts from time to time in separating the company as a legal entity. In fact, while the company legal relationships until that time had been principally based on transactions and activities between natural or real persons, namely human beings, from. Separate legal personality the concept of the corporation as a separate tegal personality is, as farrar describes essentially a metaphorical use of language, clothing the formal group with a single separate legal entity by analogy with a nattwat person vqaile obviously a fiction, the choice of metaphor or analogy is not entirely. With reference to case law discuss the meaning and effect of separate legal personality. The concept is looked at form the point of view of the origin of the separate identity of a corporation and the need for such a distinction along with the capacity and liability of a corporation. Concept developed in company law, relating to the legal status between a company limited by shares and its owners. The doctrine of separate legal personality law company.
Without more, the shareholders of a company cannot be sued to enforce contracts to which the company is a party. Though it is not necessary for law to personify, since the law might, if it. If a business is a separate legal entity, it means it has some of the same rights in law as a person. Separate personality means that the artificial legal person, the company, can do almost everything a human person can do. Stocznia gdanska v latvian shipping co 2002 2 lloyds rep 436 ca.
Although in scotland a partnership has a separate legal personality by virtue of s. Established by the house of lords in the salomon case, ii this principle delineates the legal relationship between a company and its members. Further effects of a company possessing separate legal personality. Under the concept of separate legal entity, a company will becomes a body corporate that exists separately with its. Firstly, separate legal personality and limited liability. Pdf the concept of separate legal entity is 500 years old and it means that the corporation is. Judgment company is separate from its shareholders and this should be treated as transfer.
The importance of this doctrine and its relevance in the analysis of laws relating to companies is evident in the case of salomon v a salomon and co ltd 1897 ac22, the leading case which gave effect to the separate entity principle macintyre 2012. A company is a legal person or legal entity separate from and capable of surviving beyond the lives of, its members. Corporate personality and limited liability are closely linked. This paper seeks to elaborate on the doctrine of corporate legal personality in company law and the nature of the doctrine as a doubleedged sword. A company is therefore said to have separate legal personality or corporate personality. The doctrine of separate legal personality law company business partnership essay. The doctrine of separate legal entity is a doctrine which has gained increasing importance in the analysis of company law. Separate legal entity one of the characteristic features of a corporation is the fact that it is a separate entity from the owners under the law. The distinct status of a business organization that has complied with law for its recognition as a legal entity and that has an independent legal existence from that of its officers, directors, and shareholders. Discuss the concept of separate legal entity and consequences of corporate personality on a company.
There were many problems which arose from the application of salomon. This chapter discusses the separate legal personality of companies, covering. Since 1897, the principle of the separate legal personality of a company has become a vital part of company law. The consequences of this separate legal personality were elucidated by lord davey who postulated that as a separate entity a company has the. Download as docx, pdf, txt or read online from scribd.
Human beings are normally regarded as legal persons, they are subject to the legal systems within which they find themselves. The concept of the company as a separate legal person, a metaphor of limited use like all legal fictions, can only be justified by and assessed to the extent that it serves the laws social and. In others word, the corporation is an entity just like human being created using legal and official purpose. Keywords corporate law, separate legal personality, legal entity, salomon v salomon. Jul 05, 2019 an incorporated company, united or combined into an organised body, is recognised by law as a separate legal entity, or legal person distinct from the separate personalities of the members of the body. Separate legal personality law essays essay sauce free. Salomon v salomon 2 identified that a company is not only an association of its members, but also a person. Normally legal personality is granted by law to all human beings. Artificial personality, juridical personality, or juristic personality is the characteristic of a nonliving entity regarded by law to have the status of personhood a juridical or artificial person latin. Introduction a contracts, torts, agency and trusts b misuse of the corporate form c the single economic entity d injunctions and orders e characterisation f statute. The principle was first accepted in salomon v salomon, a landmark case which is often considered to have established one of the most important principles within company law. The law, in creating legal persons, always does so by personifying some real thing. Since a company is termed as a separate legal entity in the eyes of law, it can hold property in its own name and the members cannot claim to be the owner of the.
Although they are linked, they are not the same thing. A company registered under the companies act 2006 has the legal capacity of a natural person, s 39. The principle of separate legal entity of a company has been, in fact recognized much earlier than in salomans case. The separate legal personality of a company, as aforementioned, represents one of the most fundamental principle of company law. Separate legal personality of a company law essays essay. The decision made by the house of lords in salomons case confirms gooleys observations that the doctrine of separate legal personality was a doubleedged sword puig 2000. The concept of separate legal entity in light of corporations. Petition petitioners claimed exemption from such tax on the ground that the transfer was from them individually to themselves in another name.
Corporate personality legal definition of corporate personality. Case study on separate legal entity of a company scribd. Nov, 2012 accordingly, the doctrine of separate legal personality has not been fatally undermined by the number of exceptions because the doctrine, for the most part, remains a fundamental principle of company law and the exceptions are necessary to the doctrines functionality in the modern commercial world. Nineteenth century general incorporation statutes changed the process for acquiring corporate legal personality, but did not alter the underlying fact that. Concept of separate legal entity and consequences of. Corporations can be compared to a human in that it is an artificial person as it has a separate legal personality, in. Separate legal personality of a company law teacher.
Concept of separate legal personality of a company discuss the concept of separate legal entity and consequences of corporate personality on a company. Yet, although this is a fundamental concept, it has proved extremely intractable to define and to describe satisfactorily. Court held that lee was a separate person from the company he formed, and compensation was due to the widow. Thus, the rule of corporate personality enabled lee to be the master and servant at the same time. When a company is formed by registering under the companies act 1985, it becomes a corporation with different characteristics from that of a partnership or other unincorporated body. Pdf the concept of the company as a separate legal person, a metaphor of limited use like all legal fictions, can only be justified by and assessed to. Yet, although this is a fundamental concept, it has proved extremely intractable to define. Its difference will be highlighted via reference to the facts of the case.
This article focuses on the source of corporate legal personality, applying an historical lens to show that the status of a company as a legal person or persona ficta is of long standing. Re noel tedman holdings pty ltd 1967 qd r 56 stated that a companies members may come and go but this does not affect the legal personality of the company. The idea of a company is that it has a separate legal personality to its members or directors. The doctrine of separate legal personality, as embodied in. Excerpt i a company, upon incorporation, becomes a body corporate under s. Salomon v salomon 2 identified that a company is not only an association of its members, but also a person separate from its members which is extremely significant as it carries many consequences. The various theories of legal personality are also discussed. The consequences of a corporate personality law company business partnership essay. A registered companys legal rights and obligations are wholly separate from its owners, own entitlements and duties. A corporation is a separate legal entity from its owners. The principle of legal entity principle postulates that each company in a corporate group is treated as a separate legal entity distinct from other companies within the group, and as such exercises legal powers in that regard. Salomon is the leading case regarding separate personality, stating that once a company is legally incorporated it becomes a legal person with its own rights and liabilities separate from those of its members.
687 46 1352 543 367 868 1204 1131 57 131 886 1386 363 517 925 639 632 593 496 1260 664 1577 1308 547 1489 1082 1048 1617 1640 394 1583 601 776 1275 865 166 896 428 1067 1218 1047 1232